Persia: The First Multinational Empire

“Fundamental to Jacksonville University’s mission is support for an environment where divergent ideas, theories, and philosophies can be openly exchanged and rigorously evaluated. Consistent with these principles and the concept of Academic Freedom, this course may involve the discussion of ideas that you find uncomfortable, disagreeable, or even offensive. These ideas are intended to be presented in an impartial manner, they are not intended to persuade and are not an endorsement of what you should personally believe.”

This concise guide is intended as an introductory resource. The questions posed are not central to the debates in this course, but rather serve as basic points of departure. I seek to present the material with objectivity, while acknowledging that the approach is not, and cannot be, neutral. Prof. Jorge Majfud.

Table of Contents

Questions

  1. What made the Achaemenid Empire the first to include so many diverse nations?
  2. Why did Cyrus allow people to keep their own religions and traditions?
  3. Why does the Book of Isaiah refer to a Persian ruler as God’s «chosen one»?
  4. How did satraps, roads, and a shared currency help keep the empire unified?
  5. Was Persian tolerance genuine, or was it a tool for maintaining power?
  6. How did Zoroastrian beliefs about truth and deceit become part of political speech?
  7. Which Persian concepts continued to influence later empires and even today’s governments?

Introduction: Ruling Many Peoples

«Thus saith the Lord to his anointed, to Cyrus, whose right hand I have holden, to subdue nations before him.» Isaiah 45:1

The Central Idea: Unity Without Uniformity

So far we have looked at states which ruled over one people (Egypt, the Mesopotamian empires, Assyria, Babylon). Ancient Israel developed a covenant for one people. Now we come to the sixth century BCE and the rise of the Achaemenid Persian Empire (c. 550–330 BCE) on the Iranian plateau. At its height this vast empire stretched from the Aegean Sea and Egypt to the Indus River and was perhaps the largest empire the world had seen up to that time. It ruled over dozens of different peoples, languages and religions, but made no attempt to make them Persian. All they had to do was pay.

The Persians did not try to make the peoples of the Empire Persian. Instead they created a system of unity without uniformity. At the top was a single King of Kings chosen by the god Ahura Mazda. Below him were a small number of institutions which bound the Empire together: the provinces or satrapies with royal governors; a network of roads and messengers; a single currency and a system of tribute; and a single language of administration. The rest of the institutions of a people were left in place as long as the people paid their tribute, obeyed the King and did not rebel. The Persians realized that it was cheaper to rent the loyalty of a people than to try and buy their soul.

Cyrus the Great, founder of the Persian Empire, when he conquered the city of Babylon in 539 BCE presented himself to the Babylonians as the restorer of their gods and religious practices and allowed the many peoples who had been deported by the Babylonians to return to their homes and to rebuild their temples, including the Jews. The Jewish prophet of the Exile, Second Isaiah, even called Cyrus the Great God’s “anointed” (mashiach, “messiah”), the only non-Israelite to be so called in the Hebrew Bible. Most conquerors have to be satisfied with being called by other names.

The language of the Persian Empire was Iranian. The Persian King, in his political rhetoric, identified his rule with the truth and the order (arta) and opposed the lie (drauga) and the forces of chaos, rebellion, and disorder. Obedience to the King was defined as part of the cosmic struggle between good and evil. This formula is still in use today: the ruler defines the truth and therefore also defines the rebel.

This chapter considers the problems that face any multinational state, whether it be the Roman Empire, the European Union, the United States, India or Russia. How does a single government rule over many peoples, each with its own language, religion and history? And is there a distinction between tolerance as a principle and tolerance as a smarter strategy of domination?

Key Terms

TermOriginMeaning
AchaemenidFrom Achaemenes, legendary ancestorThe ruling dynasty of the Persian Empire, c. 550–330 BCE
King of KingsOld Persian xšāyaθiya xšāyaθiyānāmThe supreme ruler above all subject kings and peoples
Satrapy / satrapOld Persian xšaçapāvan, «protector of the realm»A province and its royal governor
Royal RoadGreek sourcesHighway from Sardis to Susa, about 2,500 km, with relay stations
DaricGold coin named after DariusThe imperial gold currency; the silver siglos circulated beside it
TributeOld Persian bājiRegular payments in silver, goods, or services owed by each province
Imperial AramaicLanguage of the Near EastThe common administrative language of the empire
Ahura Mazda«Wise Lord»The supreme god of the Zoroastrian tradition, invoked by Persian kings
Arta (Avestan asha)«Truth, order»The right cosmic, moral, and political order
Drauga (Avestan druj)«The lie»Deceit, disorder, rebellion; the enemy of truth
Cyrus CylinderClay cylinder, 539 BCEBabylonian text in which Cyrus justifies his conquest

The Central Problems

1: Whose story? Most of the narrative accounts of Persia written by foreigners are the work of Greeks, in particular Herodotus (Histories, c. 430 BCE). They often depict the Persians as a lot of luxurious despots and the Greeks as free men. Persian royal inscriptions on the other hand are propaganda written to glorify the king. The Bible remembers Cyrus with gratitude. Administrative documents, such as the thousands of clay tablets found at Persepolis, offer a more everyday view, written by scribes who had no reason to lie about the price of beer.

2: Was it really «tolerance»? The word suggests modern values of religious freedom and human rights. The Cyrus Cylinder has been called the «first charter of human rights,» but most historians reject this as anachronistic: it is a traditional Mesopotamian royal proclamation in which a conqueror claims the favor of the local god. Persian tolerance coexisted with brutal repression of rebels. Every age, it seems, needs to find its own values in the past, even if it has to put them there first.

3: Using tolerance as a means of control. It was cheaper to leave local elites, laws and gods in place than to try to impose a single culture on the subjects of an empire. Is “tolerance” in empires a moral principle or a technique of rule? This question is as relevant to other empires that used to rule “indirectly” through local rulers as it was to the British in India and in Africa who discovered that the most efficient way to rule a people was to let them believe that they were still ruling themselves.

4: The Greeks, since the time of the Persians, have always contrasted Western freedom with Eastern despotism, and Persia has always been the chief example. Edward Said, in Orientalism (1978), argued that such contrasts were used by Westerners to justify their domination of the East. The East was despotic; therefore the West had to be freedom-loving. But the Persian Empire was an absolute monarchy, and in many ways more tolerant than its Greek and later rivals. How should we view this?

5: Religion and power. Were the Achaemenid kings Zoroastrians in a strict sense? Scholars debate it. But they clearly used a religious vocabulary of truth and lie, order and chaos, to define loyalty and rebellion. When a state describes its enemies as agents of chaos or evil, what happens to the possibility of legitimate dissent? Usually, it disappears.

Historical Context: From the Iranian Plateau to the World’s Largest Empire

The Persians were one of several groups of Iranian-speaking people that settled in the early first millennium BCE on the Iranian plateau, in the area north of the Medes. Like other groups, the Persians for centuries lived on the periphery of older civilizations such as the kingdom of Elam in southwestern Iran, and the great Mesopotamian powers. Like so many other groups that would go on to dominate the world, the Persians began on the periphery.

Assyria was the major power in the Near East of the 7th century BC. This empire was very military based and also very cruel, as they were proud of. After the coalition of the Medes and the Babylonians destroyed the capital of Assyria, Nineveh, in 612 BC, the world was divided into four major powers: the Medes in Iran, the Neo-Babylonian Empire of Nebuchadnezzar in Mesopotamia and the Levant (the empire that destroyed Jerusalem in 586 BC), the kingdom of Lydia in Anatolia, and Egypt.

Within thirty years of Cyrus’s rise to power, he and his son Cambyses conquered all four of the above-named empires. The Persian Empire, under the rule of Darius I, stretched from Libya and the Aegean Sea in the west to Central Asia and the Indus valley in the east. It was home to many different peoples and was estimated to have held perhaps the largest share of the world’s population of any empire in history (estimates vary widely). It lasted for some 220 years before being conquered by Alexander the Great. To the Greeks, the Persian Empire was their great enemy, against whom they defined themselves. For the peoples of the Near East, the Persian Empire was the framework of political life for more than two centuries, during which time the greater part of the civilized world, from Egypt to India, was governed by a single power.

timeline of the Achaemenid Empire · c. 559–330 BCE

The founders of the Persian Empire (Cyrus, Cambyses and Darius) created most of what is described in this chapter. Wars with Greece occurred after the empire was established, and the empire lasted for 150 additional years.

Cyrus and the Politics of Tolerance

Cyrus the Founder

Cyrus II, known as Cyrus the Great (c. 600–530 BCE), became king of Anshan, a small kingdom of Persians in the southwest of modern Iran, which was subject to the Median empire. He defeated his Median overlord Astyages in c. 550 BCE and took over his empire. Around 547–546 BCE he took over the kingdom of Lydia in the west of Anatolia, which was ruled by the legendary rich king Croesus. With Lydia he also took over the Greek cities on the Aegean coast. In 539 BCE he conquered Babylon, the most powerful city of the Near East. After taking Babylon he also took over all of Mesopotamia, Syria and the Levant. Cyrus II died in battle in Central Asia in 530 BCE and was buried in a modest stone tomb at his capital Pasargadae. The tomb of the ruler of half of the known world is smaller than the mausoleums of many minor bankers of today.

For the regional king in little more than twenty years to have become the ruler of most of the world was remarkable. Even more remarkable is his reputation. For the Babylonians, the Jews, and even many Greeks he was a just king. He is remembered by almost all the peoples of the ancient world as a great king and as a just king. Xenophon’s Cyropaedia (“The Education of Cyrus,” c. 370 BCE) described Cyrus as the ideal king, and Machiavelli and even Thomas Jefferson (who owned two copies of the book) read it. One of the founders of the American republic found on his shelf the manual of a Persian king.

The Conquest of Babylon and the Cyrus Cylinder

When Cyrus the Great arrived outside the walls of Babylon in 539 BCE, the city’s ruler Nabonidus was greatly disliked by the powerful priesthood of Marduk, the city’s chief deity. Nabonidus had lived away from Babylon for nearly a decade in the Arabian oasis of Tayma, ignored the annual New Year celebration, and elevated the moon god Sin to prominence. When a king fights with his own clergy, they often do not need to fight against foreign enemies. Cyrus defeated the Babylonian army at Opis, then entered Babylon without fighting, according to Babylonian accounts.

Cyrus’s version of the conquest of Babylon can be found on the Cyrus Cylinder, a cylindrical clay artifact written in the ancient language of Akkadian in cuneiform script. Discovered in Babylon in 1879, it is housed in the British Museum along with thousands of other artifacts belonging to peoples around the globe. This cylinder follows a traditional Mesopotamian pattern; however, its message is as follows:

1: Nabonidus had angered the gods and oppressed the people.

2: Marduk, the god of Babylon, searched for a righteous leader, selected Cyrus, and allowed him to peacefully enter the city.

3: Cyrus, «king of the world, great king, legitimate king,» restored order to the city, relieved the citizens of forced labor, and paid respect to Marduk daily.

4: also removed the statues of the gods that Nabonidus had brought into Babylon and placed them back into their original sanctuaries in other cities. In addition, Cyrus gathered all those who had been forced out of their homes and sent them back home.

The Cylinder does not refer to either the Jews or to any general concept of religious tolerance. It is simply a piece of political theater expressed through a local language and a local religious terminology: a foreign conqueror presenting himself as the servant chosen by the conquered peoples’ god. The cylinder refers to an earlier inscription of the Assyrian king Ashurbanipal; thus, Cyrus is placing himself in the tradition of legitimate Mesopotamian kings. It is, therefore, an effective example of legitimation through adaptation. Cyrus did not establish his god in Babylon. He did something far better: he claimed theirs.

The Return of the Jews

In 586 B.C., King Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylonia conquered Jerusalem and destroyed the Temple, exiling most of the elites from Judah to Babylonia, as we discussed in Chapter 4. In accordance with the biblical book of Ezra (Ezra 1:1-4; 6:3-5), King Cyrus, upon becoming king of Babylon, issued a proclamation which allowed the Jewish people to return to Jerusalem to rebuild the Temple. He also restored the holy vessels that Nebuchadnezzar had stolen. Historians have debated what the wording of the proclamation was, but it is consistent with the policies outlined in the Cyrus Cylinder.

The return of the Jews to Jerusalem was slow and incomplete. While many Jews did return, many chose to stay in Babylonia. For more than two thousand years, there existed a large, prosperous Jewish community in Babylonia. As many other diaspora communities will come to understand, exile becomes home. Those who returned to Jerusalem returned to a very small, poor province known as Yehud, which was a part of the Persian province «Beyond the River.» The Second Temple was built during the reign of Darius I (around 516-515 B.C.). During the Persian Period, as we saw in the last chapter, much of the Hebrew Bible was compiled and edited. Also during this time, many Persian appointed governors, like Nehemiah, instituted reforms. Judaism as we recognize it today was created in part through Persian rule. All identities that consider themselves to be «pure» are products of some empire.

Isaiah 45: A Foreign King as God’s Anointed

In the second part of the book of Isaiah, chapters 40-55, written by an anonymous prophet (known by scholars as Second Isaiah or Deutero-Isaiah) who lived among the exiles in Babylon around 540 BCE, as Cyrus the Great’s armies were advancing, we find the most remarkable reaction to Cyrus the Great. Here God addresses Cyrus as “his anointed” (45:1), the Hebrew mashiach, a title usually reserved for the kings of Israel.

The reaction of the prophet to the Persian emperor is extraordinary. He is a pagan, foreign emperor, who does not even know the God of Israel (v. 4). Yet he is called by God to be His instrument in the history of the world. Several ideas are brought together here.

A) Universal sovereignty. If God is the God of all the nations of the world, then even the pagan Persian king is being used by God to accomplish His purposes. Second Isaiah is the most explicit monotheist in the Bible.

B) Legitimacy through liberation. Cyrus is anointed by God because he frees the captives and allows the Temple to be rebuilt. He is not the king of Israel because of his blood or religion. He is anointed because of his deeds.

C) This small people chose to view their new imperial master as a positive force. It made sense to cooperate with the Persian Empire, so the prophecy made that cooperation an act of faith. One cannot defeat the Empire, but one can baptize it.

The chapter contains the following verse: “I form the light, and create darkness: I make peace, and create evil” (Isaiah 45:7). Many scholars believe that this verse is a polemical response to the Iranian dualism of Ahura Mazda and Ahriman, the good and evil cosmic powers (see section on Zoroastrianism). The prophet asserts that there is only one God, who creates both light and darkness, and that He uses Cyrus as His servant. The prophet’s praise of the emperor is thus combined with a correction of his theology. Few court intellectuals have managed such a feat of diplomacy.

This title, “anointed,” used for a foreign king, has had a long and very surprising history in our time. Some of the most prominent American evangelical leaders have spoken of U.S. presidents as being like Cyrus the Great, imperfect or even ungodly leaders whom God uses to protect believers. This way of reading the story of the captives’ song of freedom has turned it into a hymn of the palace, celebrating the power of empire.

Tolerance as Strategy

The policies of previous empires can help us see how unusual Cyrus’s policy was. The Assyrian Empire used terror to control its population; many of its royal reliefs showed individuals being impaled or flayed, and hundreds of thousands of people were deported from their homes to prevent them from resisting. Babylon followed a similar pattern when they exiled most of the Jews from Judah. Cyrus reversed both patterns, restoring gods and people to their native lands.

These policies were based on both practical considerations and ideology. With such a large number of different peoples, the empire could not be controlled solely through force. There were just not enough Persians available to maintain control over all of these groups. Local priests, scribes, and other elites who maintained their temples and positions of power had every reason to support the new regime. If a conquered people saw that their new ruler respected their god, they were less likely to rebel against him. In this way, Persian tolerance was more cost-effective and stable than using terror to keep control. For once, virtue and financial responsibility aligned.

However, Persian tolerance was also limited and conditional. According to Herodotus, when Cyrus’s son Cambyses conquered Egypt in 525 BCE, he mocked Egyptian religion and killed the sacred Apis bull. However, archaeological evidence from Egypt indicates that an Apis bull was buried with royal honors during Cambyses’ reign, and an Egyptian official named Udjahorresnet recorded that Cambyses restored the temple of the goddess Neith at Sais. This suggests that Greek history was susceptible to «fake news.» During the reign of Xerxes (486–465 BCE), an inscription claimed that the king destroyed a sanctuary of false gods (daivas) in a rebellious region, and Babylonian revolts were brutally suppressed. As long as people complied with Persian rule, they received tolerance. However, if people resisted, they faced the full wrath of the empire. Tolerance has always been a privilege granted only to the obedient.

This story illustrates the Persian perspective. King Darius asked some Greeks what it would take for them to eat the bodies of their deceased fathers. They responded that nothing could make them do so. He then asked members of an Indian tribe which did consume their dead what it would take for them to burn their fathers’ bodies like the Greeks did. They screamed in horror. Herodotus quoted the poet Pindar in saying, «Custom is king of all.» An empire ruling so many diverse populations understood that customs could not easily be altered, and therefore, wise rulers did not attempt to alter them. This may have been the first lesson in cultural relativism; however, instead of being taught by an anthropologist, it was taught by an emperor. Subsequent empires with missionaries and civilizing missions would require many centuries and many deaths to learn this lesson.

The Achaemenid Model: How to Run an Empire

Darius the Organizer

Although Cyrus the Great established the Persian Empire, its organization was accomplished under Darius I (r. 522–486 BCE). Darius rose to power during a time of great upheaval. Following the death of Cambyses in 522 BCE, a man who claimed to be Cambyses’s brother Bardiya took the throne. Darius, a member of a collateral branch of the royal family, along with six other nobles assassinated the man, claiming that the man was actually an impostor, a priest named Gaumata. Subsequently, many revolts occurred throughout the empire. In his own inscription, Darius states that he fought nineteen battles and captured nine rebel kings in one year. Some modern-day historians believe that Darius’s statement may have been a cover up for a usurpation. This will not be the last time that a person seizes power by accusing someone else of seizing it.

After taking control of the empire, Darius developed the administrative structures which kept the empire together for nearly two centuries. Herodotus provides insight into how the people viewed each ruler; the Persians referred to Cyrus as «father», Cambyses as «master» and Darius as «shopkeeper» due to his emphasis on establishing fixed taxes and accounting systems. Empires are founded by conquerors, but they are maintained by accountants. Darius created a new ceremonial capital city, Persepolis, and ruled from several royal cities such as Susa, Ecbatana and Babylon, traveling according to the seasons.

The Satrapies

The Persian Empire was divided into 20-30 provinces called satrapies, each of which was governed by a satrap (“protector of the realm”). Usually the satraps were members of the Persian nobility, often even relatives of the King. Local rulers, too, were sometimes appointed as satraps. The satrap collected the tribute of the province, administered justice, maintained order, raised troops and represented the King in his province. He resided in a palace built on the model of the King’s palace but on a smaller scale. Thus, every satrap was a small King.

But there was a great danger to such a system: a powerful provincial governor could rise up to become an independent King. Darius and his successors therefore applied several checks.

A) Divided authority. The commanders of the royal garrisons stationed in the provinces as well as the royal secretaries sent to the satrapies reported directly to the King, according to Greek sources.

B) Inspectors. Royal officials known to the Greeks as the “King’s Eye” and the “King’s Ear” traveled about the provinces reporting to the court. Surveillance is not a modern invention; only the technology is modern.

C) Personal loyalty. Satraps were bound to the king by family ties, marriages, gifts and the constant threat of recall or execution.

The checks on satraps worked for long periods of time, but not always. In the fourth century BCE several satraps rebelled in Anatolia, attempting to become independent kings. In addition to these instances of rebellion, satrapies eventually became hereditary, a characteristic of all appointed offices. The tension between central government control and provincial autonomy would appear in all large states after the fall of the Persian Empire, including the Roman provinces and modern federal systems.

Roads, Messengers, and the King’s Eyes

The 5,000 km long Persian Empire needed a network of communication. The Royal Road, extending from Sardis in western Anatolia to Susa in southwestern Iran, was the most famous of these roads. Herodotus reported that it had 111 relay stations, and that a traveler on foot needed about ninety days to cover it. Royal couriers on horseback, changing horses at each station, could carry messages in about a week. Power, then as now, was a matter of speed: whoever knows first, rules.

Herodotus’ praise of the Persian couriers is well known: “Neither snow nor rain nor heat nor night stays these couriers from the completion of their appointed rounds with the utmost dispatch.” This quote is inscribed on the James A. Farley Post Office building in New York City, and is often quoted as the unofficial motto of the U.S. Postal Service, whose employees do not realize that they are carrying the motto of a Persian emperor’s couriers, praised by a Greek who considered the Persians to be despots.

The Persian road network was also an administrative system. The Persepolis Fortification Tablets, thousands of clay tablets written in Elamite script around 509–493 BCE, describe the rations issued to travelers at various road stations. These rations were distributed upon presentation of sealed travel authorizations, the ancient equivalent of passports and expense accounts. Bureaucracy is older than democracy. The Persian road system served the Persian army, tax collectors, and messengers, but it also facilitated trade and the movement of ideas across Asia. It is often the case that roads are built for other purposes. Darius also completed a canal linking the Nile River to the Red Sea, which is recorded on many inscriptions found along the canal’s route.

A Common Currency and the Tribute System

Coinage was invented in the kingdom of Lydia in the late seventh century BCE. Croesus produced coins of pure gold and silver in Lydia. The Persians then used these coins in the western part of the Persian Empire where they were used for trade with the Greek world. Darius introduced the gold daric (named after him) and the silver siglos, with the king as an archer stamped on them. Twenty sigloi equaled one daric. In most of the Persian Empire people used to pay in weighed silver and in goods but the daric became a symbol of the Persian royal power and a standard of value in the Mediterranean. Persian gold was also used as a weapon, the Persians later financed Greek cities against each other. What Xerxes could not achieve with ships, his successors achieved with coins. The Greeks successfully resisted the Persian army but they were less successful in resisting Persian money.

The annual tribute of the satrapies was fixed in each case. Herodotus listed 20 tax districts and gave the payments in silver talents. The richest province was Babylonia with 1,000 talents. India paid in gold dust. Persia proper, the heartland of the empire, was exempt from payments, as was the case with the centers of most other empires. Other peoples brought so-called “gifts” of ivory and ebony from Ethiopia, of frankincense from Arabia. The quotation marks are appropriate. The great staircase of the Apadana (audience hall) at Persepolis shows the delegations of more than 20 peoples, each in its own national costume, bearing their respective products to the king. A visual expression of an empire of diversity and of submission. The diversity of the clothing and the uniformity of the direction of the gifts are the key words.

The tablets of Persepolis give insight into the sophisticated redistributive economy of the Persian Empire in the heartland of the Empire. Thousands of workers, called kurtash, were paid in rations of grain, wine and beer. Some of these workers were even deportees or prisoners of war. Women workers, female supervisors who received more rations than the male ones, and even special rations for mothers after giving birth, with more rations for a boy than for a girl, were also recorded. All this in the most generous of bureaucracies.

Many Languages, One Administration

The empire did not impose the Persian language on other peoples. Instead, royal inscriptions were written in three languages, Old Persian (in a cuneiform script probably developed under Darius for this purpose), Elamite and Babylonian Akkadian, and even in Egyptian hieroglyphs, where appropriate. In daily administration throughout the empire the Persians used Imperial Aramaic, a Semitic language already widespread in the Near East, written on parchment and papyrus. Even the rulers did not govern in their own tongue. Aramaic documents survive from Egypt to Afghanistan, including the letters of the Egyptian satrap Arshama and the papyri of a Jewish military colony on the island of Elephantine in the Nile. In one of them (419 BCE) the Persian authorities even transmit instructions concerning the Jewish festival of Unleavened Bread. A Persian bureaucracy regulating a Jewish holiday in Egypt, in Aramaic: globalization is older than we think.

A common administrative language was used in addition to the languages of the provinces. This allowed for communication between officials from different parts of the empire, while at the same time allowing conquered peoples to retain their own languages. This model was followed by many other empires and multilingual states, although there were also many that chose to try and make conquered peoples forget their native tongue before teaching them the language of the conqueror.

Local Laws, Local Gods

As a rule, the Persians left local legal systems and institutions intact, and, in some cases, even promoted them. In a late Egyptian text, Darius is said to have ordered the collection of Egyptian laws. In the Bible, Artaxerxes, king of Persia, authorizes Ezra to teach and enforce “the law of thy God” in Judah. He is to back this law with the authority of the Persian king, so that any who fail to observe it are to be treated as if they had failed to observe the king’s law (Ezra 7:25–26). Some scholars refer to this policy as “imperial authorization.” In effect, the empire recognized the local laws of its subjects and, by granting them the backing of royal authority, made them instruments of imperial control.

The Persians initially used local tyrants to govern the Greek cities of Ionia, but after a major revolt, Mardonius, the Persian general, allowed democracies to be established in Ionia (Herodotus 6.43). In other words, a great despotic empire allowed democracies to be established in order to ensure that the empire would receive the loyalty and the tribute of the people who were governed by those democracies. Later, Western empires would establish dictatorships in the name of democracy, but that is another story. Babylon was allowed to keep its temples and its scribes, the Phoenician cities were allowed to keep their kings and to provide the imperial navy, Egypt was allowed to keep its pharaonic rituals, and the Persian kings were allowed to appear in Egyptian temples as pharaohs.

Limits and Contradictions

The Achaemenid model was not a paradise of tolerance:

1: In an absolute monarchy, the king’s power is theoretically limitless. His subjects, even the highest nobles, are referred to as his “servants” (bandaka). Guests perform proskynesis — either a bow or a prostration — when greeting the king; this was viewed as humiliating by the Greeks, yet the Greeks had no problem expecting such behavior from their own slaves.

2: Extreme punishment of rebellions. Darius boasts about cutting off the noses, ears and tongues of rebel leaders, and then impaling them. After the Greek cities of Ionia revolted (499–494 BCE), Persia destroyed Miletus, enslaving or deporting all of its people.

3: Extraction. Silver was extracted through tribute from the provinces to be sent to the royal treasury. According to ancient sources, when Alexander captured Persepolis and Susa, he took tens of thousands of talents of hoarded silver and gold. Heavy taxes in Babylonia may have caused poverty and revolt.

4: Wars of expansion. Darius and Xerxes attempted to conquer Greece in 490 and 480-479 BCE, but were defeated at Marathon, Salamis and Plataea. These battles became the foundation for a myth of freedom against tyranny that the West has repeated for 2500 years, often neglecting to mention that the «free» Greeks also had slaves.

The Persian model demonstrates some of the strengths and dangers of a practical Empire. While it decreased the amount of fear needed to control its citizens by allowing them to maintain their cultural identity, it still rested on conquest, tribute and the ultimate authority of one individual.

Order Versus Chaos: Zoroastrianism as Political Language

Zarathustra and the Cosmic Struggle

The religion of the ancient Iranian peoples is called Zoroastrianism after its prophet, Zarathustra, whom the Greeks called Zoroaster. His dates are quite uncertain, with estimates ranging from 1500 BC to 600 BC, but most scholars now place him before 1000 BC on linguistic grounds. Zarathustra’s teachings are found in the Gathas, a series of hymns written in the very archaic language of the Avesta, the scriptures of Zoroastrianism. Few people have had so great an impact on the religious imagination of so many people and yet left so little evidence of their own lives.

Zarathustra taught that Ahura Mazda (the “Wise Lord”) created the good world. He taught that there is a struggle in the world between two spirits: a good spirit and a bad spirit (or, as they were later called, Angra Mainyu or Ahriman). The good spirit is associated with asha (or arta in Old Persian), which means truth, order, justice, etc. This is similar to the Egyptian concept of Ma’at which we studied in Chapter 2. The bad spirit is associated with druj (or drauga in Old Persian), which means lie, deceit, chaos, destruction, etc.

Several features of this vision would prove enormously influential:

A) The essence of the religion is moral choice. A person chooses between truth and lie. Good thoughts, good words and good deeds are the three pillars of the Zoroastrian religion.

B) A History with a Direction: This struggle between good and evil will not last forever. At the end of the world, there will be a final judgment, the dead will rise, and evil will be defeated. This world will then be destroyed and a new world will be created. Later Zoroastrian texts even speak of a future savior, Saoshyant, who will come to the world to usher in a time of great peace and prosperity.

C) Individual judgment: After death, each person must cross a bridge where his or her deeds are weighed. The good cross to paradise and the evil fall into the abyss.

There is some debate among scholars as to how strictly the Achaemenid kings adhered to Zarathustra’s teachings, given that they did not acknowledge the prophet in any of their inscriptions and worshiped other gods as well. However, the kings’ inscriptions are heavily imbued with the terminology of Ahura Mazda, truth, and the lie. Kings are usually more concerned with the practical use of a prophet’s vocabulary than they are with his teachings.

Truth and the Lie at Behistun

The Behistun Inscription, dated to around 520 BCE, is the most significant political document of the Achaemenid Empire. It is carved on a cliff face approximately 100 meters above a road in Western Iran. The inscription was written in three languages: Old Persian, Elamite, and Babylonian. On top of the text there is a relief showing Darius with his foot on the body of the usurper, standing before a line of captured rebel kings tied together at the neck. Hovering above the kings is the winged figure associated with Ahura Mazda.

This inscription is considered one of the earliest examples of propaganda. In 1835, British officer Henry Rawlinson risked his life to copy the inscription. His work provided the key for deciphering cuneiform, just as the Rosetta Stone provided the key for understanding Egyptian hieroglyphs. What started out as a text designed to present one king’s version of history ultimately opened up the archives of an entire civilization. Thus, propaganda can sometimes serve the truth by accident.

According to Darius, his rise to power was a cosmic battle. Darius stated that he became King through the will of Ahura Mazda. He explained that the provinces rebelled against him because they were deceived by the Lie. The rebel leaders claimed to be Kings. By contrast, Darius presented himself as a follower of Truth, who neither lied nor did anything wrong. He stated that he did not oppress either the weak or the powerful. He advised future Kings to protect themselves from the Lie and to punish anyone who followed it.

Darius, whom many historians suspect of usurpation, carved on a mountain 100 meters high that he had never lied.

To describe political rebellion as a Lie is to state that it is a moral and cosmic disorder. To remain loyal to the King is to remain loyal to Truth. At Darius’ tomb at Naqsh-e Rostam, a later inscription further develops the image of the ideal ruler. This ideal ruler loves what is right; controls his anger; rewards those who cooperate with him; punishes those who do harm; and does not wish for the weak to be wronged by the strong, nor for the strong to be wronged by the weak.

That last clause is particularly relevant. Every system of government which protects the strong from the weak eventually claims to be neutral.

His son Xerxes used similar language in his “Daiva Inscription.” He recorded that in a country where false gods (daivas) were worshipped, he destroyed their sanctuary and established proper worship of Ahura Mazda according to Arta.

There is a limit to tolerance here. If a people rebels, its gods may also be declared false. Like peoples, gods are respected as long as they behave.

The King as Defender of Order

The Persian model of kingship combined two ideas that may seem contradictory:

1: A universal, inclusive empire, which respected the gods and laws of its many peoples.

2: A dualistic political theology in which the king embodies truth and order, and his enemies are the embodiment of lie and chaos.

In practice, the two ideas worked together. Every people was allowed to keep its own customs, provided it accepted the king’s order. Thus, those who resisted the king’s order defined themselves as part of the lie, as opposed to the truth of the king. The king was the gardener of the world, guarding the cultivated order against the wilderness of chaos. Persian palaces were surrounded by walled gardens, called paradaida, which the Greeks called paradeisos, and which became our word “paradise”. Thus, paradise was originally a walled garden owned by a king. This image is worth reflecting upon: a perfect order, surrounded by walls, reserved for a few people, and protected against those outside.

This way of talking about politics has been very long-lasting. Many rulers and many states have said that they were fighting against darkness, against barbarism, against chaos, against evil. Such language can inspire people to fight against injustice but it can also make it impossible to reach a compromise with the enemy and thus turn the enemy into an enemy of the cosmos. Once the enemy is evil everything is permitted against him, and the first thing to suffer is truth which the king claimed to defend..

Legacy: From Persepolis to Our Time

Alexander, Rome, and the Imperial Model

The Persian Empire of the Achaemenids was conquered by the Macedonian King Alexander the Great between 334 and 330 BCE. Alexander burned the palace of Persepolis in 330 BCE, perhaps as retribution for the burning of the Athenian palaces 150 years earlier, perhaps because he was drunk. In any case, history does not always make a distinction between the actions of a king on behalf of his policy and those of a hangover. However, the conqueror adopted much of the conquered Persian Empire. He kept the system of satrapies, as well as many of the Persian satraps. He adopted elements of the Persian royal garb. He tried to introduce Persian court ceremonial, such as the practice of making officers bow before him, but was unsuccessful. In 324 BCE, he presided at Susa over the mass marriage of dozens of his officers to Persian noblewomen. His successors, the Seleucids, ruled much of the former Persian Empire with Persian institutions. The Greek who came to free Asia from Eastern despotism, ended up dressing as a Persian king. In sum, the conqueror is often conquered by the conquered.

The Roman Empire was also composed of many different peoples, and like the Persians, they organized the Empire into provinces, governed by governors. The Romans also constructed a vast system of roads, with a state courier service, and a uniform system of currency. The official language of administration was Latin in the West, and Greek in the East. As long as the subjects paid their taxes, kept order, and honored the emperor, the Romans were quite tolerant of the local cults and laws. Rebelion was severely punished, as evidenced by the destruction of the Jerusalem Temple in 70 CE, similar to the destruction of Miletus by the Persians. Rome, which would later present itself as the heir to the freedom of the Greeks, ruled in much the same manner as the Persian despots.

Persian Statecraft in Later Empires

There were two more great empires in Iran itself, the Parthian Empire (247 BCE–224 CE) and the Sasanian Empire (224–651 CE). The Sasanian Empire made Zoroastrianism the state religion, with a powerful priesthood. After centuries of fighting Rome and Byzantium, the Sasanian Empire was conquered by Arab Muslim armies in the seventh century CE. The new caliphates adopted much of the Sasanian administrative system, with its registers, taxation, court ceremonies and Persian-speaking bureaucracy. The Abbasid caliphate, established in 750 CE, located its capital in Baghdad, near the former Sasanian capital, and assimilated so much of the Persian culture that historians speak of the Persianization of Islamic government. Once again, the conquerors were taught to govern by the conquered.

The Achaemenid principle of ruling many peoples by recognizing their communities reappeared in many forms:

A) The Ottoman millet system allowed various religious communities to manage their religious, educational, and even some aspects of family law, while being subject to the authority of their leaders, in return for loyalty to the Ottoman state and payment of special taxes.

B) The Mughal emperor Akbar (r. 1556–1605) promoted a policy of “universal peace” (sulh-i kul) for Muslims, Hindus, and other religions. Persian remained the language of administration in much of India until the 1830s when the British replaced it with English.

C) The British Empire attempted to govern its colonies through the medium of local kings and chiefs, i.e. through their traditional laws. The Ugandan scholar, Mahmood Mamdani (Citizen and Subject, 1996) argued that the British policy of ‘Indirect Rule’ actually created a form of ‘decentralized despotism’ in the colonized countries, i.e. rule by colonial power through local chiefs who were answerable to the colonizer, not to their people. This was the costume of ‘respect for tradition’. The colonial office was the tailor.

These examples illustrate the Persian lesson that tolerance can be used as a technique of control, rather than as a virtue. The difference between a tolerant empire and a free society is that of a guest and a resident: the guest is allowed to stay, but the resident has the right to.

Zoroastrian Ideas in Judaism, Christianity, and Islam

Many scholars, including Mary Boyce, have described the impact on Judaism of the religious contacts between Persia and the Jews in the Persian Period and subsequently, and thus also on Christianity and Islam. Many of the ideas that later became important in Judaism, such as the idea of a final judgment, the resurrection of the dead, a cosmic opponent of good (Satan), hierarchies of angels and demons, a future savior, and an end of history in which good is victorious, have parallels in the religion of Iran. The degree of the influence of Iranian religion on Judaism is a subject of discussion, but there are some ideas that could have developed on their own. The wise men from the east in the Gospel of Matthew are called the Magi, the name of the Iranian priestly class. The religions that were later to call Persia the land of infidels carried in the center of their imagination Persian furniture.

The religion of the Persians survives today as a small religion, with its followers living in Iran, and above all as the Parsis of India, who migrated to India after the Islamic conquest and played a major role in the economic life of modern Bombay (Mumbai). The German philosopher Friedrich Nietzsche made use of the prophet Zarathustra in his Thus Spoke Zarathustra (1883–1885), because Zarathustra was the first to make morality a cosmic struggle and so Nietzsche wanted to have the prophet overcome morality.

Cyrus in Modern Politics

Cyrus the Great is a political symbol for many causes. This is the privilege and curse of the dead who left a good reputation.

I) Iranian nationalism. In 1971, the last Shah of Iran, Mohammad Reza Pahlavi, celebrated 2,500 years of Iranian monarchy in a lavish ceremony at Persepolis. He presented himself as the heir of Cyrus the Great. His sister presented the Cyrus Cylinder to the United Nations, where it is displayed to this day. The government of the time portrayed it as the “first charter of human rights” while simultaneously torturing dissidents and suppressing freedom of speech and other human rights. The extravagant ceremony in a poor country further fueled the hatred of the people for the regime, culminating in the 1979 revolution. The Islamic Republic has an ambivalent relationship with pre-Islamic Persia, but Cyrus the Great is highly revered by many Iranians, some of whom visit his tomb at Pasargadae, occasionally as a form of protest. The same dead king served first the Shah against the people, and then the people against the ayatollahs.

II) and American memory. Thomas Jefferson owned two copies of Xenophon’s Cyropaedia. When U.S. President Harry Truman, who recognized the State of Israel in 1948, was introduced in 1953 as the man who had helped create Israel, he reportedly answered, «I am Cyrus.» In 2018, when the United States moved its embassy to Jerusalem, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and some American evangelical leaders compared President Donald Trump to Cyrus. Twenty-five centuries later, the title of messiah is still available to foreign rulers, provided they move the right buildings.

III) Political theology. A number of evangelical authors have developed the “Cyrus” model for Christians supporting leaders of whom they do not approve, in order that God may use them to protect his people. Other Christians, however, have criticized this reading of the biblical story, which, in order to justify Christians supporting power, turns a story of liberation from imperial power on its head. This is the old alchemy of ideology: to turn the liberator of captives into the patron saint of convenience.

Empire, Diversity, and Federalism Today

The Achaemenid question (how can one state govern many peoples?) is a very modern political question.

1: The national state. This system attempts to create a single people with one language and a single identity. In such a state minorities can politely disappear.

2: Federalism – the government of a country is divided into different levels, for example a central government and several regional governments, with their own institutions (e.g. USA, Switzerland, India, Germany, Brazil).

3: Multiculturalism and minority rights as presented by political philosophers such as Will Kymlicka in his book Multicultural Citizenship (1995) to defend the cultural rights of minorities in a common citizenship.

4: Supranational unions such as the European Union (EU) whose official slogan is ‘United in diversity’ (the motto of Darius, king of the Persian Empire, written in Latin).

The above solutions have the same advantages and dangers as the Persian model. There are advantages of having a common framework (roads, currency, laws, administration etc.) and acknowledging the local differences, but there are also the dangers that ‘diversity’ is used to hide inequalities of power, and that the central power can define as enemies of order the critics of its decisions. The Persian kings were tolerant; however, tolerance given by an absolute ruler is not the same as the rights of citizens. What is given from above can be taken away from above. What is taken from below must be defended on a daily basis.

Comparative Analysis: Persia Among the Ancient States

In addition to inheriting tools from previous civilizations such as writing, bureaucracy, tribute and divine legitimacy, Persia was able to apply these tools to a much larger world than those that had come before. This is illustrated in the table below which compares Persia to the models we have previously examined. Each column represents centuries of change.

 Assyria and BabylonEgyptIsrael (Hebrew Bible)Achaemenid Persia
Territory and peoplesMany peoples, conquered by forceOne people along one riverOne people, under a covenantDozens of peoples, three continents
Ruler’s legitimacyChosen by the city’s godsThe king is a godGod alone is king; kings under the lawChosen by Ahura Mazda; King of Kings
Policy toward subjectsTerror and mass deportationUnification under one cultureCovenant community; protection of the strangerTolerance of local gods, laws, and elites; return of deportees
AdministrationProvinces under Assyrian governorsScribes and nomarchs under the pharaohTribes, elders, later royal officialsSatrapies, inspectors, royal secretaries
EconomyTribute, temple and palace estatesRedistributive grain economyFamily land in trust; debt releaseFixed tribute, coinage (daric), rations, trade along roads
LanguageAkkadian, later AramaicEgyptianHebrewMany languages; Aramaic for administration
Political theologyGods of the city and empireMa’at against chaosProphets judge kings by God’s lawTruth (arta) against the Lie (drauga)
Treatment of rebelsBrutalRebellion as cosmic chaosProphets may denounce kingsBrutal; rebels as followers of the Lie
Lasting legacyImperial terror as a warningDivine kingship, the state as storehouseHigher law, prophetic critique, JubileeMultinational administration, roads, currency, tolerance as policy

In the end, the Achaemenid Empire established the first large-scale empire in history that was to last for centuries by tolerating differences between its subject peoples, as opposed to suppressing them. The formula of common institutions at the center of the empire, local autonomy for the subject peoples, and a sacred language of order defining loyalty to the ruler was to be copied, either deliberately or unconsciously, by Alexander the Great, Rome, the caliphates, the Ottomans, the British and, in more democratic forms, by modern federations and unions. The open question for a course on ideologies is whether such tolerance can be established as a right of the governed, or whether it remains, as in Persia, a gift that the rulers can withdraw at any time, when the governed forget to be grateful.

Summary

Back to courses: Syllabi

Related Topics


Comentarios

Deja una respuesta

Descubre más desde Escritos Críticos

Suscríbete ahora para seguir leyendo y obtener acceso al archivo completo.

Seguir leyendo