Controlled Democracies, Participatory Dictatorships

Democracias controladas, dictaduras participativas (Español) · Démocraties contrôlées, dictatures participatives (Français) · Kontrollierte Demokratien, partizipative Diktaturen (Deutsch) · Democracias controladas, ditaduras participativas (Português) · ديمقراطيات مُتحكَّم بها، ديكتاتوريات تشاركية (العربية) · 受控的民主,参与式的专制 (中文) · Контролируемые демократии, партисипативные диктатуры (Русский)

In mid-October, only 30 percent of Americans approved of Donald Trump’s performance. Since Gallup began these polls in the 1930s, only five presidents have fallen lower: Truman, bogged down in Korea; Nixon, days before resigning; or George W. Bush amid the ruins of Iraq and Wall Street.

In these elections, 54 million citizens (22%) voted early. Anxiety usually signals a desire for change and predicts a tsunami. But we should not confuse frustration with change. Voters do not choose another system; they choose another administration of the same system. Power, real power, is not put to a referendum and never will be. No system has ever changed through an election. Slavery was not abolished at the ballot box but in a civil war. The socialist reforms of the 1930s were not born of some debate of ideas but of the Great Depression.

Well, we know this; it’s folklore: Democrats and Republicans were always two factions of the same party—the party of finance capital, of the military-industrial complex, and of the corporations that fund them both. They argue passionately about abortion or public restrooms; rarely about the Pentagon’s budget or the concentration of wealth that writes the laws and decides the wars. In a market democracy, the voter chooses the wrapping, not the contents. It’s group therapy.

Even so, elections matter. For an immigrant, driving while watching the rearview mirror for an ICE agent is not the same as going home to enjoy a beer, even if it is no more than the relief of the slave.

On the other hand, the Gaza Generation is shaking up the board, and a fistful of people are trying to stop it. Thomas Massie, the libertarian lawmaker from Kentucky, won his seat seven times while opposing aid to Israel, but in May 2026 he lost the most expensive primary in history: more than 32 million dollars, some nine million of it contributed by pro-Israel groups, pushed him out.

Elon Musk donated some 446 million dollars to the Republicans (a tip, for his fortune), more than the top ten Democratic candidates received. Buying politicians who will later sign billion-dollar contracts with the donors’ companies is legalized corruption, as obscene as the Epstein cesspool.

Thus the electoral system of liberal democracies has become—if it ever was anything else—the main instrument of extortion for the elites, the real power. A president may play at being the most powerful man in the world, but always up to a certain limit. If he crosses it, the system replaces him. That is why elections are so important. Not because they give power to the people, but because they function as permanent extortion over whoever governs.

Is there anything new? Something. Among those under thirty, rejection of Trump and of traditional politics is overwhelming. The Gaza Generation inherited student debt, impossible rents, and a planet on fire, while watching in real time what the mainstream media called the «Palestinian conflict.» Its opinion of Israeli apartheid was already unfavorable years before the Hamas attack of 2023; the genocide radicalized it. Like the students who pressed against South African apartheid in the 1980s, the latest campus movement was a moral blow that today translates into a new group of successful politicians. Unconditional support for Israel ceased to be a bipartisan consensus and became a questioning that reached capitalism itself as dogma.

That generation already has faces. Zohran Mamdani won the New York mayoralty with the Democratic machine against him. Jon Ossoff will win a Senate seat in conservative Georgia. In Michigan, Abdul El-Sayed—son of Egyptian immigrants, the doctor who championed «Health for all,» who withstood a culture war against his name and his religion and did not hesitate to condemn the wars in Iran and Palestine—will become the first Muslim senator. In Texas, where Democrats have not won a Senate race since 1988, James Talarico, a 36-year-old former teacher who campaigned against millionaire donors, with a Christianity closer to Liberation Theology than to the Prosperity Preachers, could win the Senate seat.

What is new is not that these left-wing politicians exist, but that they can now win. Even Trump has suggested ending the 3.8 billion dollars in annual military aid to Israel (money that flows back to American arms manufacturers). It is an old maneuver, but it shows that even the most reactionary power is starting to speak the language of the Gaza Generation.

After the defeat, Trump will do what a good salesman does: while sinking, he sells his life jacket. As when Bolsonaro lost in Brazil, he will lie that he was not involved. It is the narrative of the businessman, but also that of the believer: if lightning strikes a temple, it is «a divine test»; if it strikes a union hall, it is «God’s punishment.» Faith never adjusts to the facts; the facts adjust to faith.

The first temptation of the triumphant Democrats will be impeachment. It is probably not in their interest. Removing a president requires two-thirds of the Senate, and a failed trial would turn Trump into a hero or a martyr. It is more likely that, with control of committees in Congress, pressure will grow to declassify the Epstein files. If a serious revelation were combined with the psychoanalytic need to kill the declining father, impeachment would cease to be unthinkable even for Republicans.

On the external front, the danger is distraction. Washington and Israel are preparing plans to resume attacks on Iran, because when a government loses at home, the solution lies in victories abroad. War is the oldest way to change the subject. Also to sustain an economy that grows for a few.

The real battle of 2028 will not be between Democrats and Republicans, but within the Democratic Party. The machine and its donors will try what they always try with rebels: absorb them, tame them, or fund their rivals in the primaries. On the other side, Vice President JD Vance (a candidate manufactured by Silicon Valley, with a fictional biography) or Secretary Marco Rubio (with his record of summary executions in the Caribbean and of dead children in Cuba’s hospitals) will have to sell another version of Make America Great Again, a dogma that cannot survive any accountability.

The central problem is not a president or a party, but a structure that concentrates wealth at an unprecedented rate and converts it into media, platforms, campaigns, and laws. Redistribution, demonized as socialism, is what is least discussed. Some elections can be lost; the obscene accumulation of capital is never in doubt.

Without deep and sustained reforms, the 2040s will see a social intifada that is unthinkable today—not because peoples are violent, but because when the powerful close every door to reform, social justice finds its 1789.

The new Democrats of the Gaza Generation can win an election. What they have not yet won is the opportunity to change what one or two elections will never change. If they don’t do it, unleashed history will—and history is far less kind.

Jorge Majfud, November 3, 2026.

Originally published in Página/12 (in Spanish)

Related topics

→ All writings by Jorge Majfud in English

Descubre más desde Escritos Críticos

Suscríbete ahora para seguir leyendo y obtener acceso al archivo completo.

Seguir leyendo